top of page

Catering Menu for Anthony's Deli & Market

Small serves 12-15 people
Large serves 30 people

SUB PLATTERS

Amsterdam's sub sandwiches have you running to the Southside. Anthony's sub sandwich trays are made fresh from local ingredients. Taste the difference.

Hoagies Turkey, Ham, Italian Mix Assortment

Our sub sandwich trays aim to satisfy. Get fresh locally sourced vegetables with tasty meat on homemade bread.

Small Hoagies serve 12 - 15 people

$40.00

​

Large Hoagies serve 30 people

$85.00

​

Wraps Turkey, Ham, Italian Mix Assortment

Our prized wrap sandwiches made with fresh locally sourced ingredients to order.

Small Wraps serve 12 - 15 people

$45.00

​

Large Wraps serve 30 people

$95.00

​

BREAKFAST

Anthony's Deli is all about offering you mouth-watering breakfast sandwich catering, fresh fruit trays, and a variety of pastries that light up your morning.

Breakfast Sandwich

Experience Anthony's breakfast sandwich catering. Our tray of breakfast sandwiches comes with a variety of bacon, double egg & cheese, sausage, and ham.

$8.00

Fresh Fruit Platter

Anthony's got the enticing fresh fruit platters to help you start your day right and keep your guests energized. This fresh fruit tray is an assortment of healthy fresh delicious fruit.

Small Fruit Platter serves 12-15 people

$40.00

​

Large Fruit Platter serves 30 people

$85.00

​

Pastry Platter

Anthony's offers a variety of assorted muffins, pastries and donuts. We proudly present pastry trays from local dessert vendors. We also make pastry's in house in our gluten-free bakery.

Small Pastry Platter for 12-15 people

$55.00

​

Large Pastry Platter for 30 people

$115.00

​

APPETIZERS

Kick off your meal with the best appetizers in Amsterdam, NY. Anthony's selection of delicious appetizers varies from simple finger food for parties to extravagant hand passed bites of delight.

Imported Italian Meat & Cheese

At Anthony's we pride ourselves in offering imported Italian meat and cheese. The classic cheese, meat, and cracker tray is always a welcome treat for holiday parties or any event.

Small Meat and Cheese for 12-15 people

$45.00

​

Large Meat and Cheese for 30 people

$95.00

​

Charcuterie Board

Specialty Charcuterie meats, cheeses, and other surprises in an appetizing sweet box.

Small Charcuterie Board for 12-15 people

$55.00

​

Large Charcuterie Board for 30 people

$115.00

​

Herb Grilled Vegetable Platter

Vegetables marinatated in a house herb sauce and grilled to tender perfection. Anthony's herb-grilled vegetables inspire everyone to enjoy their veggies.

Small Grilled Vegetable tray: 12-15 ppl

$40.00

​

Large Grilled Vegetable tray: 30 ppl

$85.00

​

Buffalo Chicken Dip

Add some zing to any party with Anthony's Buffalo Chicken Dip.

Small Buffalo Chicken Dip for 12-15 ppl

$55.00

​

Large Buffalo Chicken Dip for 30 people

$115.00

​

Spinach and Artichoke Dip

This warm inviting tasty spinach and artichoke dip brings joy to all. Bonus points for eating healthy greens and loving it!

Small Spinach & Artichoke Dip: 12-15 ppl

$40.00

​

Large Spinach & Artichoke Dip: 30 ppl

$85.00

​

Baked Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms

This is the mushroom appetizer for mushroom lovers. Hearty stuffed mushrooms with tastebud-approved sausage.

Small Stuffed Mushroom for 12-15 people

$65.00

​

Large Stuffed Mushroom for 30 people

$135.00

​

Chicken Wings Boneless or Bone-In

Anthony's bone-in or boneless wings come with 4 sauce choices: BBQ, Honey Mustard, Buffalo, or Garlic Parm. Find out why people are raving about Anthony's party wings.

Small Boneless Wings for 12-15 people

$45.00

​

Large Boneless Wings for 30 people

$95.00

​

Small Bone-In Wings for 12-15 people

$60.00

​

Large Bone-In Wings for 30 people

$125.00

​

ENTREES

Quick and healthy lunch ideas and fast comfort food meals. We take pride in our homemade cooking and delight in bringing you the nostalgic comfort food you long for with a creative delicious modern twist.

The Best Mac and Cheese

Amsterdam's crave-worthy classic mac and cheese you dream about with some meaty upgrade options.

Small Mac & Cheese serves 12 - 15 people

$45.00

​

Large Mac & Cheese serves 30 people

$95.00

​

Penne Alla Vodka

Classic alla vodka sauce with a rich home made flavor. Put smiles on faces of all ages with penne alla vodka.

Small Penne Alla Vodka for 12-15 people

$45.00

​

Large Penne Alla Vodka serves 30 people

$95.00

​

Penne Alfredo

The house made alfredo sauce to share and make friends with. This classic penne alfredo is sure to make you popular.

Small Penne Alfredo serves 12-15 people

$40.00

​

Large Penne Alfredo serves 30 people

$85.00

​

Classic Lasagna with Meat

Fill the room with the saucy smell and cheesy, meaty joy that our lasagna catering brings. Satisfy your guests' cravings with a traditional lasagna.

Small Lasagna with Meat for 12-15 people

$55.00

​

Large Lasagna with Meat for 30 people

$115.00

​

Shaved Steak Sub Sandwich

The Southside of Amsterdam has the steak sub sandwich you travel to find. We roast our steak to juicy perfection. Then top it with grilled peppers, onions, and cheddar cheese. Served with homemade hoagie rolls.

Small Steak Sub Sandwich for 12-15 ppl

$55.00

​

Large Steak Sub Sandwich for 30 people

$115.00

​

Sausage Peppers & Onions

An age old classic that doesn't disappoint. See why this traditional homemade dish is famous. Served with hoagie rolls.

Small Sausage Pepper & Onions: 12-15 ppl

$50.00

​

Large Sausage Pepper & Onions: 30 ppl

$105.00

​

BBQ Pulled Pork

Anthony's BBQ Pulled Pork is slow cooked in house and served with fresh crusty hoagie rolls. Get pulled pork catering on demand.

Small Pulled Pork serves 12-15 people

$55.00

​

Large Pulled Pork serves 30 people

$115.00

​

BBQ Ribs

The Southsides finger-licking good Barbecue Ribs you can't get out of your mind. The melt-in-your-mouth flavor satisfying Amsterdam's hunger.

Small BBQ Ribs serves 12-15 people

$60

​

Large BBQ Ribs serves 30 people

$125.00

​

BBQ Beef Brisket

Tender slow-cooked barbecue beef brisket cooked with just the right spices in house. Savory rich flavor to delight your senses at Anthony's Amsterdam Deli.

Small BBQ Beef Brisket for 12-15 people

$55.00

​

Large BBQ Beef Brisket for 30people

$115.00

​

BBQ Chicken

Crispy cooked smoky tender flavor barbecue chicken. Anthony's juicy BBQ chicken lights up any room.

Small Bone in BBQ Chicken for 12-15 ppl

$45.00

​

Small Boneless BBQ Chicken: 12-15 ppl

$45.00

​

Large Bone in BBQ Chicken for 30 ppl

$95.00

​

Large Boneless BBQ Chicken for 30 ppl

$95.00

​

Chicken Parmesan

Anthony's breaded crispy chicken parmesan with tangy marinara sauce keeps your tastebuds raving while satisfying your hunger.

Small Chicken Parmesan for 12-15 people

$50.00

​

Large Chicken Parmesan for 30 people

$105.00

​

Country Fried Chicken

A little piece of country in Amsterdam, NY this country fried chicken has your palette singing. Crispy country fried chicken is served with our house homemade gravy.

Small Country Fried Chicken: 12-15 ppl

$50.00

​

Large Country Fried Chicken: 30 ppl

$105.00

​

The Best Chicken Marsala

Anthony's savory chicken marsala made from the finest ingredients, taste the difference.

Small Chicken Marsala for 12-15 people

$50.00

​

Large Chicken Marsala for 30 people

$105.00

​

Italian Meatballs

Try the best meatballs at Anthony's Amsterdam Deli. Italian marinara style meatballs have a slightly crisp exterior with a tender interior.

Small Italian Meatballs for 12-15 people

$55.00

​

Large Italian Meatballs for 30 people

$115.00

​

Chicken Meatballs

Try Anthony's Deli's healthy meatball. Ditch the red meat and discover the tasty chicken meatball alternative.

Small Chicken Meatball for 12-15 people

$55.00

​

Large Chicken Meatball for 30 people

$115.00

​

Garlic Herb Chicken Breast

Grilled herb chicken breast finished in an Italian garlic sauce. A tasty light healthy dinner idea that satisfies.

Small Garlic Herb Chicken for 12-15 ppl

$55.00

​

Large Garlic Herb Chicken for 30 ppl

$115.00

​

Fried Chicken Tenders

Quality fried chicken tenders, an American classic. Fried chicken tenders are fun for all ages.

Small Chicken Tenders for 12-15 people

$50.00

​

Large Chicken Tenders for 30 people

$105.00

​

SIDE DISHES

Finish any meal with these side dishes. Anthony's Deli side dishes are sure to be a hit at your party or event.

Freshly Baked Homemade Rolls

Try Anthony's Deli's best-kept secret . Our house-made rolls and breads are a delight.

Small Homemade Rolls serves 12-15 people

$18.00

​

Large Homemade Rolls serves 30 people

$41.00

​

Farm Fresh Garlic Green Beans

Fresh locally sourced green beans prepared with a touch of garlic.

Small Garlic Green Beans for 12-15 ppl

$25.00

​

Large Garlic Green Beans for 30 ppl

$55.00

​

Parmesan Crusted Broccoli

Enjoy Anthony's cheesy parmesan crusted broccoli.

Small Parmesan Broccoli for 12-15 people

$25.00

​

Large Parmesan Broccoli for 30 people

$55.00

​

Honey Buttered Carrots

Buttered and drizzled with honey, these Honey Buttered Carrots are a healthy treat.

Small Honey Carrots for 12-15 people

$25.00

​

Large Honey Carrots for 30 people

$55.00

​

Wild Rice

Anthony's Wild Rice is a treat with any entree.

Small Wild Rice for 12-15 people

$25.00

​

Large Wild Rice for 30 people

$55.00

​

Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes

Anthony's cheesy spin on scalloped potatoes is rich and inviting in any crowd.

Small Scalloped Potatoes for 12-15 ppl

$40.00

​

Large Scalloped Potatoes for 30 ppl

$85.00

​

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Anthony's creamy mashed potatoes with a hint of garlic.

Small Mashed Potatoes for 12-15 people

$35.00

​

Large Mashed Potatoes for 30 people

$75.00

​

SALADS

Welcome your guests with a fresh salad they can't turn down. Anthony's variety of fresh salads bring smiles to any party or event.

Pasta Salad

Anthony's Deli Pasta Salad is made with assorted vegetables, black olives, a variety of cheeses, and specialty meats with a house-made dressing.

Small Pasta Salad for 12-15 people

$25.00

​

Large Pasta Salad for 30 people

$55.00

​

Macaroni Salad

Who doesn't love a classic macaroni salad? This traditional mayo-based macaroni salad brings a nostalgic comforting vibe to your gathering.

Small Macaroni Salad for 12-15 people

$25.00

​

Large Macaroni Salad for 30 people

$55.00

​

Cole Slaw

Anthony's fresh cole slaw completes any meal with a zing of flavor.

Small Cole Slaw serves 12-15 people

$25.00

​

Large Cole Slaw serves 30 people

$55.00

​

Broccoli Salad

Anthony's fresh salads leave you wanting more and this broccoli salad is no exception.

Small Broccoli Salad serves 12-15 people

$35.00

​

Large Broccoli Salad serves 30 people

$75.00

​

Potato Salad

Anthony's Deli Potato Salad is a flavor packed traditional mayo based potato salad.

Small Potato Salad serves 12-15 people

$35.00

​

Large Potato Salad serves 30 people

$75.00

​

Antipasto Salad

Anthony's Deli Antipasto Salad is a delicious healthy fresh salad packed with a variety of greens, cucumbers, tomato, celery, red onion, salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese.

Small Antipasto Salad for 12-15 people

$45.00

​

Large Antipasto Salad for 30 people

$95.00

​

Greek Salad

This is the Greek Salad to share with new friends to make them lasting friends. Anthony's Deli delivers a fresh salad made with a variety of healthy greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, celery, onion, feta cheese, and pepperoncini.

Small Greek Salad for 12-15 people

$35.00

​

Large Greek Salad for 30 people

$75.00

​

Summer Berry Mixed Green Salad

Anthony's Deli Summer Berry Mixed Green Salad tastes like a sunny summer fresh breeze. Crafted with mixed greens, cucumber, tomato, onion, feta cheese, candied walnuts, and fresh berries.

Small Summer Berry Salad: 12-15 people

$35.00

​

Large Summer Berry Salad: 30 people

$75.00

​

Mixed Green Salad

Anthony's Deli Classic Mixed Green Salad is an inviting and refreshing choice. Made with various greens, tomato, red onion, and cucumber.

Small Mixed Green Salad for 12-15 people

$35.00

​

Large Mixed Green Salad for 30 people

$75.00

​

Caesar Salad

Anthony's Deli Classic Caesar Salad reminds you why it's a classic. An arrangement of romaine lettuce, parmesan, and homemade croutons drizzled in a house-made Caesar dressing.

Small Caesar Salad for 12-15 people

$40.00

​

Large Caesar Salad for 30 people

$85.00

​

House Cobb Salad

An enticing blend of fresh mixed green, tomato, onion, avocado, bacon, egg, chicken, and creamy blue cheese crumbles. Anthony's Cobb Salad is a sure way to leave a lasting satisfied impression on your guests.

Small Cobb Salad serves 12-15 people

$40.00

​

Large Cobb Salad serves 30 people

$85.00

​

DESSERTS

At Anthony's Deli we pride ourself on offering a variety on our dessert catering menu. Our dessert catering is rich with Amsterdam's specialty dessert vendors and our own housemade gluten-free baked items.

Assorted Dessert Platter

At Anthony's our dessert platter is like picking a special treat from multiple Amsterdam bakeriers. Our dessert catering menu features specialty desserts that are local favorites. Seasonal availability applies to the dessert catering menu.

Small Dessert Platter for 12-15 people

$50.00

​

Large Dessert Platter for 30 people

$105.00

​

Brownie or Cookie Platter

Enjoy a brownie or cookie platter from our bakery. Yes we have gluten-free baked goods. Featuring Amsterdam's finest dessert vendors.

Small Brownie/ Cookie Platter: 12-15 ppl

$45.00

​

Large Brownie/ Cookie Platter: 30 ppl

$95.00

​

DRINKS

Add beverages to your catering order.

Beverages

An assortment of soda, water, juice, and sparkling water.

Small Beverage for 15 people

$30

​

Large Beverage for 30 people

$60

​

PIZZA

Cheese Pizza

Homemade marinara with whole milk mozzarella

$17

Chuck's Pie

Fresh mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers, balsamic vinegar, tomato, fresh basil with a garlic crust

$22

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Chicken, applewood bacon, tomato, mozzarella cheese with buttermilk ranch

$22

Mega Meat Pie

Shaved steak, sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and ham

$22

Veggie Lover White Pie

Mushrooms, onions, black olives, broccoli, tomato, ricotta cheese, garlic sauce, fresh mozzarella

$22

bottom of page